Personal
E-petitions considered pointless...
(null)/(null)/(null) (null) | Permalink
I try not to blog too much about this kind of thing,
but a while ago I
mentioned that the UK Government set up an
online E-petition allowing you to lobby
parliament from the comfort of your own web
browser.
Well, regardless of the arguments for and against ID cards I (and presumably 28,000 other people) just got this response from His Nibbs Himself, Mr. T. Blair. I guess the fact that it starts off by acknowledging that this particular petition had one of the largest responses followed (more or less) by 'and here's why we're not going to listen' kind of sums up the governments attitude to this kind of a thing. (I hope I'm wrong, on this, I really do.)
Anyway, here is the full reply :
The e-petition to "scrap the proposed introduction of ID cards" has now closed. The petition stated that "The introduction of ID cards will not prevent terrorism or crime, as is claimed. It will be yet another indirect tax on all law-abiding citizens of the UK". This is a response from the Prime Minister, Tony Blair.
The petition calling for the Government to abandon plans for a National ID Scheme attracted almost 28,000 signatures - one of the largest responses since this e-petition service was set up. So I thought I would reply personally to those who signed up, to explain why the Government believes National ID cards, and the National Identity Register needed to make them effective, will help make Britain a safer place.
Well, regardless of the arguments for and against ID cards I (and presumably 28,000 other people) just got this response from His Nibbs Himself, Mr. T. Blair. I guess the fact that it starts off by acknowledging that this particular petition had one of the largest responses followed (more or less) by 'and here's why we're not going to listen' kind of sums up the governments attitude to this kind of a thing. (I hope I'm wrong, on this, I really do.)
Anyway, here is the full reply :
The e-petition to "scrap the proposed introduction of ID cards" has now closed. The petition stated that "The introduction of ID cards will not prevent terrorism or crime, as is claimed. It will be yet another indirect tax on all law-abiding citizens of the UK". This is a response from the Prime Minister, Tony Blair.
The petition calling for the Government to abandon plans for a National ID Scheme attracted almost 28,000 signatures - one of the largest responses since this e-petition service was set up. So I thought I would reply personally to those who signed up, to explain why the Government believes National ID cards, and the National Identity Register needed to make them effective, will help make Britain a safer place.
The petition disputes the idea that ID cards will help reduce crime or terrorism. While I certainly accept that ID cards will not prevent all terrorist outrages or crime, I believe they will make an important contribution to making our borders more secure, countering fraud, and tackling international crime and terrorism. More importantly, this is also what our security services - who have the task of protecting this country - believe.
So I would like to explain why I think it would be foolish to ignore the opportunity to use biometrics such as fingerprints to secure our identities. I would also like to discuss some of the claims about costs - particularly the way the cost of an ID card is often inflated by including in estimates the cost of a biometric passport which, it seems certain, all those who want to travel abroad will soon need.
In contrast to these exaggerated figures, the real benefits for our country and its citizens from ID cards and the National Identity Register, which will contain less information on individuals than the data collected by the average store card, should be delivered for a cost of around £3 a year over its ten-year life.
But first, it's important to set out why we need to do more to secure our identities and how I believe ID cards will help. We live in a world in which people, money and information are more mobile than ever before. Terrorists and international criminal gangs increasingly exploit this to move undetected across borders and to disappear within countries. Terrorists routinely use multiple identities - up to 50 at a time. Indeed this is an essential part of the way they operate and is specifically taught at Al-Qaeda training camps. One in four criminals also uses a false identity. ID cards which contain biometric recognition details and which are linked to a National Identity Register will make this much more difficult.
Secure identities will also help us counter the fast-growing problem of identity fraud. This already costs £1.7 billion annually. There is no doubt that building yourself a new and false identity is all too easy at the moment. Forging an ID card and matching biometric record will be much harder.
I also believe that the National Identity Register will help police bring those guilty of serious crimes to justice. They will be able, for example, to compare the fingerprints found at the scene of some 900,000 unsolved crimes against the information held on the register. Another benefit from biometric technology will be to improve the flow of information between countries on the identity of offenders.
The National Identity Register will also help improve protection for the vulnerable, enabling more effective and quicker checks on those seeking to work, for example, with children. It should make it much more difficult, as has happened tragically in the past, for people to slip through the net.
Proper identity management and ID cards also have an important role to play in preventing illegal immigration and illegal working. The effectiveness on the new biometric technology is, in fact, already being seen. In trials using this technology on visa applications at just nine overseas posts, our officials have already uncovered 1,400 people trying illegally to get back into the UK.
Nor is Britain alone in believing that biometrics offer a massive opportunity to secure our identities. Firms across the world are already using fingerprint or iris recognition for their staff. France, Italy and Spain are among other European countries already planning to add biometrics to their ID cards. Over 50 countries across the world are developing biometric passports, and all EU countries are proposing to include fingerprint biometrics on their passports. The introduction in 2006 of British e-passports incorporating facial image biometrics has meant that British passport holders can continue to visit the United States without a visa. What the National Identity Scheme does is take this opportunity to ensure we maximise the benefits to the UK.
These then are the ways I believe ID cards can help cut crime and terrorism. I recognise that these arguments will not convince those who oppose a National Identity Scheme on civil liberty grounds. They will, I hope, be reassured by the strict safeguards now in place on the data held on the register and the right for each individual to check it. But I hope it might make those who believe ID cards will be ineffective reconsider their opposition.
If national ID cards do help us counter crime and terrorism, it is, of course, the law-abiding majority who will benefit and whose own liberties will be protected. This helps explain why, according to the recent authoritative Social Attitudes survey, the majority of people favour compulsory ID cards.
I am also convinced that there will also be other positive benefits. A national ID card system, for example, will prevent the need, as now, to take a whole range of documents to establish our identity. Over time, they will also help improve access to services.
The petition also talks about cost. It is true that individuals will have to pay a fee to meet the cost of their ID card in the same way, for example, as they now do for their passports. But I simply don't recognise most claims of the cost of ID cards. In many cases, these estimates deliberately exaggerate the cost of ID cards by adding in the cost of biometric passports. This is both unfair and inaccurate.
As I have said, it is clear that if we want to travel abroad, we will soon have no choice but to have a biometric passport. We estimate that the cost of biometric passports will account for 70% of the cost of the combined passports/id cards. The additional cost of the ID cards is expected to be less than £30 or £3 a year for their 10-year lifespan. Our aim is to ensure we also make the most of the benefits these biometric advances bring within our borders and in our everyday lives.
Yours sincerely, Tony Blair
|
Aliens in my office...
(null)/(null)/(null) (null) | Permalink
Hopefully soon I'll be moving house and, therefore,
office. I had the new office pretty much planned out
already, but I didn't anticipate stumbling across
something as cool as these Space Invader wall decorations.
Make yourself heard, nerd!
(null)/(null)/(null) (null) | Permalink
In a move that's either crazy or inspired MySociety
and the government have launched an online petitions
service.
I've no idea what the outcome of this will be, or indeed if anyone at Whitehall will even take notice, but there's certainly some worthy causes.
Here's a few I've signed, there are probably more that I should - let's hope that they have some effect, eh?
Scrap ID Cards
Stop using the threat of terror to pass laws that are illeberal and ineffective
Create an exception to copyright law to allow for private copies of personal use, format shifting etc.
I've no idea what the outcome of this will be, or indeed if anyone at Whitehall will even take notice, but there's certainly some worthy causes.
Here's a few I've signed, there are probably more that I should - let's hope that they have some effect, eh?
Scrap ID Cards
Stop using the threat of terror to pass laws that are illeberal and ineffective
Create an exception to copyright law to allow for private copies of personal use, format shifting etc.
My new Nokia 6233
(null)/(null)/(null) (null) | Permalink
I broke my Motorola Razr a while back, I'm not sure
what happened to it exactly but it was probably
related to my habit of leaving it in my back pocket
and sitting on it. Still, I never really got on with
the UI, it was pretty clunky for what looked like a
phone from the future and I needed a change. I have
drawers full of old mobile phones and have been using
a Nokia 6600 as my backup, but it's big and old and
scratched and a bit broken from my dropping it a few
times.
So it's down to Phones For You Are Us and see what I can get for free. "I can't really justify spending money on mobiles when they give them away for free," I explained to the (now) somewhat crestfallen sales man. So he left me with five or six plastic models of phones to play with in the hope that I'd get bored and wander off. I didn't. I already had it in mind that I was probably going to get another Nokia and my price limit of free precluded most of the fancy ones. However, I liked the 6233 and after an hour of waiting for T-Mobile to give me the OK walked out of the shop with a new phone.
A Nokia 6233, yesterday.
"And is it any good?", I hear you ask. "Yeh, s'alright", I reply. It's got pretty much everything I've ever wanted from a phone, except...
It doesn't sync with iSync (yet). This has happened to me before (I'm always on the bleeding edge of free phones, it would seem) and anyway it's not normally a big deal as there's usually a work-around. After a bit of googling I found http://web.mac.com/the_reamer/iWeb/S60/iSync.html with instructions on syncing your Nokia 6233 with iSync. It's FREE, works perfectly, is made in the UK and it comes with a nice icon of the phone that will be more than adequate until Apple adds the required support in themselves.
The site also had Nokia themes which you can buy to make you phone look like a mac. Given that the iSync plugin was free I figured I'd buy one and here it is (sorry it's a bit blurred but I couldn't get the autofocus to do it's thing on the phones screen...)
OSXy themes for Nokia 6233, E61, N80, N73 and N93 are available here http://web.mac.com/the_reamer/iWeb/S60/Buy.html
So it's down to Phones For You Are Us and see what I can get for free. "I can't really justify spending money on mobiles when they give them away for free," I explained to the (now) somewhat crestfallen sales man. So he left me with five or six plastic models of phones to play with in the hope that I'd get bored and wander off. I didn't. I already had it in mind that I was probably going to get another Nokia and my price limit of free precluded most of the fancy ones. However, I liked the 6233 and after an hour of waiting for T-Mobile to give me the OK walked out of the shop with a new phone.
A Nokia 6233, yesterday.
"And is it any good?", I hear you ask. "Yeh, s'alright", I reply. It's got pretty much everything I've ever wanted from a phone, except...
It doesn't sync with iSync (yet). This has happened to me before (I'm always on the bleeding edge of free phones, it would seem) and anyway it's not normally a big deal as there's usually a work-around. After a bit of googling I found http://web.mac.com/the_reamer/iWeb/S60/iSync.html with instructions on syncing your Nokia 6233 with iSync. It's FREE, works perfectly, is made in the UK and it comes with a nice icon of the phone that will be more than adequate until Apple adds the required support in themselves.
The site also had Nokia themes which you can buy to make you phone look like a mac. Given that the iSync plugin was free I figured I'd buy one and here it is (sorry it's a bit blurred but I couldn't get the autofocus to do it's thing on the phones screen...)
OSXy themes for Nokia 6233, E61, N80, N73 and N93 are available here http://web.mac.com/the_reamer/iWeb/S60/Buy.html
Q. When is a review not a review?
(null)/(null)/(null) (null) | Permalink
Beer money
(null)/(null)/(null) (null) | Permalink
Well, I’ve been really pleased with the response to
the few utilities that I’ve released through this
site. I’m not yet at the point where I can
quit the day job or anything, but I am at the point
where I can buy a few beers from the proceeds which,
really, is what it’s all about.
So here’s a big ‘Cheers!’ to all of you who have supported me through your donations, kind words and feedback.
So here’s a big ‘Cheers!’ to all of you who have supported me through your donations, kind words and feedback.
Java black belt
(null)/(null)/(null) (null) | Permalink
JavaBlackBelt.com is a neat idea,
it’s a community for Java and Open Source skills
assessment. However, unlike others such as
BrainBench it doesn’t cost money
to sit the tests. It costs time.
Each exam requires a certain number of contribution points which you earn by authoring new questions or commenting and editing existing ones. On passing an exam you get ‘Knowledge Points’ which you can add together to get different belt grades (yellow, orange, green, blue, brown and black).
I find it a useful resource for keeping my ninja coding skills sharpened.
http://javablackbelt.com/UserView.wwa?userId=259522
Each exam requires a certain number of contribution points which you earn by authoring new questions or commenting and editing existing ones. On passing an exam you get ‘Knowledge Points’ which you can add together to get different belt grades (yellow, orange, green, blue, brown and black).
I find it a useful resource for keeping my ninja coding skills sharpened.
http://javablackbelt.com/UserView.wwa?userId=259522
Free-wheeling Artist
(null)/(null)/(null) (null) | Permalink
This site http://personaldna.com tells you
what you are.
I’m a free wheeling artist. My personal said so.
I’ve no idea what it means, but the sliders are fun.
I’m a free wheeling artist. My personal said so.
I’ve no idea what it means, but the sliders are fun.